Ben & Jay's Pizzeria

Overview

Ben & Jay's Pizzeria in Lawton, Oklahoma, has become a local favorite for pizza lovers in the area. Located at 529 SW C Ave, this cozy pizzeria offers a variety of delicious pizzas that cater to all tastes. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Margherita or a unique creation with unexpected toppings, you'll find something to enjoy. What makes this spot stand out is not only the food but the experience that comes with it.

The menu at Ben & Jay's Pizzeria is as diverse as it is mouthwatering. Customers can choose from a range of specialty pizzas, pastas, and sides, all prepared with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The pizza dough is made from scratch daily, ensuring every bite has that perfect chewy texture with a golden crisp on the outside. For those with dietary restrictions or preferences, there are gluten-free crust options available, and the toppings can be customized to suit vegan or vegetarian diets.

One of the standout pizzas is the "BBQ Chicken Pizza," which features tender pieces of grilled chicken, smoky barbecue sauce, red onions, and a blend of cheeses. It’s a bold combination that has become a customer favorite. For those who prefer something a little more traditional, the Ben & Jay's Pizzeria classic “Pepperoni Pizza” is always a hit. It’s loaded with perfectly melted cheese and savory pepperoni, making it an irresistible choice for many.

Apart from the pizzas, Ben & Jay's offers a variety of pasta dishes. The “Baked Ziti” is another popular item, filled with ziti pasta, marinara sauce, and layers of melted mozzarella. It’s the kind of comforting dish that brings people back again and again. For an appetizer, you can’t go wrong with their “Garlic Knots,” a perfect blend of soft, buttery dough with a delightful garlic flavor, making them the ideal starter before your pizza arrives.

What really sets Ben & Jay's Pizzeria apart from others is its friendly, welcoming atmosphere. The staff are known for their excellent customer service, making you feel right at home from the moment you walk in. The restaurant has a casual vibe, perfect for a family dinner or a quick meal with friends. Whether you’re dining in or opting for takeout, the food is always served hot and fresh.

The location itself is easy to find, nestled right in the heart of Lawton, making it an accessible option for both locals and visitors alike. The pizzeria also offers delivery, so you can enjoy their mouthwatering dishes from the comfort of your home. Many patrons also rave about the online ordering system, which makes picking up or delivering your favorite meal a breeze.

Reviews of Ben & Jay's Pizzeria are overwhelmingly positive, with customers consistently praising the food quality and the restaurant’s friendly ambiance. Some patrons have shared that the pizzeria is their go-to spot for family gatherings, date nights, or just a casual dinner out. The consistency in both the food and service is another reason why people return again and again.

Beyond the pizza, the pizzeria is involved in the local community, hosting events like pizza-making classes and special promotions during local festivities. This sense of community involvement adds an extra layer of charm to the already beloved restaurant.

For anyone visiting Lawton or anyone living in the area, Ben & Jay's Pizzeria is a must-try. With its delicious menu options, fantastic customer service, and inviting atmosphere, it’s easy to see why it has become a staple in the community. Whether you're in the mood for a pizza night or craving something comforting, this pizzeria delivers on all fronts.

Good to know

Service options

✓ No-contact delivery ✓ Delivery ✓ Takeaway ✓ Dine-in

Highlights

✓ Fast service ✓ Serves local specialty

Popular for

✓ Lunch ✓ Dinner ✓ Solo dining

Accessibility

✓ Wheelchair-accessible car park ✓ Wheelchair-accessible entrance ✓ Wheelchair-accessible seating

Offerings

✓ Alcohol ✓ Beer ✓ Cocktails ✓ Comfort food ✓ Quick bite ✓ Small plates

Dining options

✓ Lunch ✓ Dinner ✓ Dessert ✓ Table service

Amenities

✓ Toilet

Atmosphere

✓ Casual ✓ Cosy ✓ Quiet

Crowd

✓ Groups

Payments

✓ Credit cards ✓ Debit cards

Children

✓ Good for kids ✓ Kids' menu

Parking

✓ Free of charge street parking ✓ Free parking lot ✓ Parking

Photos

Location

Reviews

- No ratings yet 158 reviews
Amazing 184
Great 15
Okay 8
Not Great 6
Terrible 10
Jordan C

We came for lunch at opening time on a Saturday and the entire experience far surpassed my expectations. First, the menu options are great. We got a kickin’ chicken pizza and a cheese pizza as well as a gyro- which was one of the best I have had locally. Service was great, the restaurant is beautiful and clean, and we will absolutely return.

Ashley Patterson

The food came out piping hot and (more importantly) tasted amazing! We got a variety of foods: fried pickles, buffalo wings, pizza, and pasta and nothing disappointed. It’s a quaint little brick building with a lot of charm. We liked it a lot and will definitely be back.

NIHELA BRAZILLE

Hidden gem in Lawton that feels like home the moment you walk in ,I was delivering a DoorDash order and picked up a salad for a customer , it looked so fresh! Everything was colorful, crisp, and neatly packed, and the order was ready right on time. You can tell they care about presentation and quality, not just speed. The restaurant itself has a cozy, welcoming vibe. The red awning and “We Are Family” sign outside fit perfectly with the friendly service inside. Even during busy hours, staff stays polite, quick, and organized. Fresh, flavorful ingredients Clean and inviting atmosphere Friendly staff who greet you with a smile Fast pickup and accurate orders If their salad looked that good, I can only imagine how amazing the pizza and wings are! Definitely a spot I’ll be trying for myself soon, Ben & Jay’s is a Lawton favorite for a reason.

James Brooks

We got our order to go but inside was nice. We got the Santa Fe, ricotta be kidding me, a cheese pizza for the kids and the pizza rolls. Absolutely amazing. All of it is delicious. Wish I would have taken photos before we ate it. So very happy to have found this place.

Kacie Morris

We had a post-Thanksgiving family gathering that also turned into a belated birthday celebration for my husband. Since he and I both have special dietary needs, we’re always a little cautious about treats, but Edy completely surprised him with a perfect and delicious birthday dessert. The pizza was fantastic, and Edy’s kindness and attention made the occasion feel every bit as special as it was. We’ll definitely be back, and we genuinely hope to have service from her again. Please support local- enjoy great food, and appreciate the people like Edy who truly take care of us! We also had the back area to ourselves, and it was the perfect spot to laugh, talk, and catch up.

Matthew Rayburn

Recently ordered food from Ben and Jay’s and we were less than impressed. Don’t get me wrong, the food was decent but really not worth what they charge. We ordered the kids chicken fingers for our daughter and they were so unbelievably dry it was like trying to tear apart jerky. Our pizza and fries were cold despite the fact we received our food in less than an hour. The pretzel sticks were warm and 10/10 though. Overall, not the worst experience we’ve ever had, but also nothing to write home about. This is just our opinion based off our experience though.

miriah kuch

The personal pizzas were AMAZING! Best in town hands down! My picky eater toddlers devoured the kids cheese pizza. There was only one waitress but she was incredible attentive. The restaurant is super cute! Loved the atmosphere.

Write a review